Small business website redesign: signs, costs and a step by step plan

Small business website redesign: signs, costs and a step by step plan
Short answer

Redesign your small business website when it looks dated, is hard to use on a phone, brings visits but few calls or form leads, or you cannot update it yourself. A redesign with a Fiverr Pro team usually costs $500 to $3,000 and takes 2 to 4 weeks; agencies often charge $5,000 or more. Keep your URLs, phone number, forms and Google Business Profile details the same, and 301 redirect any page that moves.

Most small business websites do not need a new design every year. They need one when the site starts costing you customers: calls that do not come in, forms nobody fills in, or a page you would rather not send to a new client. This guide covers how to tell, which kind of redesign you need, what it costs in 2026 and how to run it so you keep your rankings and your leads.

We redesign small business websites on WordPress and Webflow, so the prices and timelines below come from our own published Fiverr packages and projects.

Signs your small business website needs a redesign

Go through this list with your current site open on your phone, not only on your laptop. Most small business visitors find you on a phone.

SignWhat it costs youUsual fix
It looks dated next to your competitorsVisitors trust the competitor who looks more establishedRefresh or redesign
It is hard to use on a phone: tiny text, buttons too close, sideways scrollingMobile visitors leave before they callRedesign
People visit but rarely call or fill in a formTraffic from Google and ads is wastedRedesign of key pages and calls to action
You cannot update it yourselfOld prices, hours and services stay onlineRebuild on a platform with a visual editor
It is slow to loadVisitors leave before the page appearsRebuild or technical fixes
Your services or brand changedThe site describes a business you no longer areRedesign with new content
It was made with a template or AI builder and looks like everyone elseNothing makes you memorableRedesign

Speed is easy to check: the Core Web Vitals report in Google Search Console shows how your pages load for real visitors. If only one or two signs apply, a refresh may be enough. If three or more apply, plan a proper redesign. Sites first made with an AI builder have their own problems, covered in why AI websites look generic.

Refresh, redesign or rebuild: which one you need

"Redesign" covers three different jobs. Pick the right one before you ask for quotes, because the price and the risk to your rankings are very different.

OptionWhat changesWhen it fitsTypical cost with us on Fiverr
RefreshColors, fonts, images and spacing. Platform, structure and URLs stayThe site works, it just looks datedNew design from $385; applying it to your current site is quoted after we see it
RedesignLayout, page structure and copy on key pages. URLs stay where they canVisitors arrive but do not call, or the site fails on phonesDesign from $385, build from $825 on WordPress or $840 on Webflow
Rebuild on a new platformNew platform and templates, every old URL redirectedYou cannot edit the site, the platform is slow or costly, or it was made with an AI builder5-page WordPress site $1,845; Webflow from $840; AI-built sites rebuilt in WordPress from $600

Most small businesses we work with need the middle option: a redesign of the pages that bring customers, on a platform they can edit. Our website redesign service explains how we choose between the three after an audit.

Southern National Roofing website before redesign
Southern National Roofing website after redesign by SkyDesigner

Above: a roofing company website before and after our redesign. The services, contact details and calls to action stayed. The layout, hierarchy and look changed.

What a small business website redesign costs

A redesign is priced much like a new website, because the design and build work is similar. What moves the price most is the number of unique page layouts, whether you supply the copy and photos, and any booking, shop or membership features.

Who does itTypical costTimelineWhat you usually get
You, with a website builderA monthly plan plus your own timeDays to weeks of eveningsA template with your content
Fiverr freelancerAbout $80 to $7003 to 10 daysA theme or page builder setup, 1 to 5 pages
Fiverr Pro or Top Rated teamAbout $500 to $3,0001 to 4 weeksA custom design you approve first, then a responsive build
AgencyOften $5,000 to $25,000+6 to 12+ weeksWorkshops, research, design, build and a retainer

These are typical market ranges, not quotes. Our website cost guide explains where they come from. As a real example, our own Fiverr packages are a website design in Figma from $385, a 5-page WordPress design and build for $1,845 and a Webflow site from $840, checked on November 19, 2026. Fiverr adds a buyer service fee at checkout, explained in Fiverr fees for buyers. After launch, budget for the domain and hosting or a site plan.

How to keep a redesign affordable

  • Design the homepage first. It sets colors, type and section styles, so the inner pages go faster.
  • Reuse what works. Copy, photos and pages that already bring calls can move to the new design.
  • Limit unique layouts. Ten service pages built from one template cost far less than ten different designs.
  • Stay on your platform if it is not the problem. A refresh on WordPress is cheaper than a move to a new platform.
  • Skip features you will not use. A blog you never update or an animation nobody notices still costs money.

What to keep so you do not lose customers

A redesign should change how your site looks and works, not how customers find and contact you. Put these on a list before design starts and check them again on launch day:

  1. Your URLs, especially the service and location pages that bring calls. Keep them where you can, and 301 redirect any that change. Our website redesign SEO checklist covers this step by step.
  2. Your business name, address, phone and hours, exactly as they appear on your Google Business Profile. Google says businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results.
  3. Click-to-call buttons and contact forms. Send a test from every form on the new site and confirm the email arrives.
  4. Booking, quote, chat and payment tools, plus the logins to the accounts behind them.
  5. Reviews and testimonials, including any review widgets.
  6. Analytics and tracking: Google Analytics, ad pixels and call tracking numbers.
  7. Your business email. If your email runs on the same domain, the email records in your DNS have to stay untouched when the website moves to new hosting.
  8. Legal pages such as the privacy policy, and the cookie banner if you use one.
On small business redesigns, the page that matters most is often not the homepage. It is a service page that ranks for a service in your city and brings the calls. We find those pages in Search Console first, keep their URLs and the sections that answer customer questions, and redesign around them. The homepage gets the new look; the pages that earn money keep doing their job.

How a small business website redesign works, step by step

This is how a 5 to 10 page redesign usually runs with us. With a Fiverr Pro team it takes about 2 to 4 weeks, depending mostly on how quickly content and feedback come back.

  1. Audit: which pages bring traffic, calls and form leads, what is slow and what customers ask about.
  2. Page plan: the list of pages that stay, merge or go, and which copy needs updating.
  3. Homepage design in Figma: you approve the look before anything is built.
  4. Inner pages: designed in the same style, desktop and mobile.
  5. Build on a staging address, so your current site stays live until launch.
  6. Launch: redirects, forms, tracking, page titles and a new sitemap in Search Console.
  7. First month: check Search Console for errors and compare calls and form leads with the old site.

For more detail on each stage, see our website design process and how long it takes to build a website.

Which platform to choose for the redesign

PlatformGood forWatch out for
WordPressOwners who want booking, WooCommerce or many plugins, and a choice of hostingUpdates and plugins need care: use managed hosting or a care plan
WebflowDesign-led sites, and teams that want to edit pages visually with hosting includedA site plan from $15 a month billed yearly, and fewer plugins
ShopifyBusinesses that sell products onlineA monthly plan plus app and payment fees

If you are on Wix or Squarespace, the site is simple and you are happy editing it there, a refresh inside your current builder may be all you need. We design and build on WordPress, Webflow and Shopify. To compare the first two, read Webflow vs WordPress.

Questions to ask before you hire

  • Will you design the pages first, so I can approve them before the build?
  • Are mobile layouts included in the price?
  • Will you keep my URLs and set up redirects for any that change?
  • Is copywriting, hosting or a premium plugin license included, or extra?
  • Who owns the design file and the website after delivery?
  • What support do I get after launch?

Clear answers to these tell you more than the portfolio. To compare sellers, see the best web designers on Fiverr and our guide to getting a website built on Fiverr.

Related guides

Is your small business website due for a redesign?

We check which pages bring you calls today, redesign the site in Figma and rebuild it on WordPress or Webflow with every old URL redirected.

Website Redesign →

FAQ

Usually $500 to $3,000 with a Fiverr Pro team and $5,000 or more with an agency. With us, a design in Figma starts at $385 and a 5-page WordPress redesign and build is $1,845.

There is no fixed schedule. Redesign when the site stops doing its job: it looks dated, fails on phones, does not bring leads or you cannot update it. A refresh in between keeps it current.

Not if you keep URLs where you can, 301 redirect the ones that change and keep the content ranking pages rely on. Some movement for a few weeks after launch is normal.

A 5 to 10 page redesign usually takes 2 to 4 weeks with a Fiverr Pro team, depending on how quickly you send content and feedback. Agencies often take 6 to 12 weeks or more.

Sources
Bojan Sandic

Founder of SkyDesigner. Fiverr Pro Vetted designer, selling on Fiverr since 2014 with 24,500+ reviews.

Vetted Pro
Top Rated ◆◆◆